top of page
Search

Standardization guide.

Writer: Þráinn Arnar Þráinsson
Þráinn Arnar Þráinsson
Nov 2
3 min read

How confusing is it when one trainer tells you to do something one way, and the next time you fly with another trainer he tells you the opposite? Or when the same performance in the simulator gets a pass from one check airman and a debrief full of criticism from another?

Most pilots have been there. It has been an ongoing battle in aviation for years. Pilots end up flying for the person in the right seat instead of flying to a standard, and the grades in their training file say as much about the instructor as about the pilot. There is a clear need for more robust standardization of the people who train and check us.


What is standardization?

Standardization means that every instructor and check airman in an organization trains and grades to the same standard. A pilot should get the same message and the same grade for the same performance, whoever is sitting behind them.

That does not mean every instructor has to teach in exactly the same way. Instructors will always have their own style. What must be the same is the standard they measure against, the words they use to describe a performance, and the grade they give for it.

In competency-based training, that standard is set by competencies. ICAO defines nine pilot competencies:

•          Application of Procedures (APK)

•          Communication (COM)

•          Flight Path Management – Automation (FPA)

•          Flight Path Management – Manual (FPM)

•          Knowledge (KNO)

•          Leadership and Teamwork (LTW)

•          Problem Solving and Decision Making (PSD)

•          Situational Awareness (SAW)

•          Workload Management (WLM)

Each competency is described by observable behaviours: things an instructor can actually see and hear the pilot do. Grading against observable behaviours, instead of against a general impression, is the foundation of standardization.


How to standardize in three steps

Step 1: Agree on one framework and one grading scale

Start by writing down what you are grading and how.

•          Use the competencies and their observable behaviours as the only basis for grading.

•          Define each point on your grading scale in plain words. For example, what does a “3” look like for Workload Management, and what separates it from a “4”?

•          Agree on the language used in debriefs, so that a pilot hears the same terms from every instructor.

Put it in a short, practical document that every instructor and check airman has and uses. If the standard only exists in people’s heads, there is no standard.


Step 2: Calibrate the graders

A written standard is not enough. People read the same words differently. The graders themselves have to be calibrated.

•          Have all instructors and check airmen grade the same performance: a recorded simulator session, or a live session observed by several graders.

•          Compare the grades and talk through the differences. Why did one instructor give a 3 and another a 4? Which observable behaviours did each of them see?

•          Agree on the correct grade and the reason for it, and add the example to your guidance.

Repeat this regularly, not only when a new instructor starts. Calibration drifts over time.


Step 3: Monitor, feed back and keep it going

Standardization is not a one-off course. It has to be maintained.

•          Record grades by competency, and look at the data by instructor and by check airman. If one person grades consistently higher or lower than the rest, that is a conversation to have.

•          Observe instructors and check airmen at work on a regular basis, and give them feedback against the same standard they use on pilots.

•          Hold recurrent standardization sessions where trends, difficult cases and changes to procedures are discussed.

The same data shows where your pilots are strong and where they are weak, so the next training cycle can target what actually needs work.


Why it matters

When training and checking are standardized, pilots know what is expected of them, instructors can trust each other’s grades, and the training records start to show the real strengths and weaknesses of each pilot. That is what allows an operator to catch a weakness early and correct it with targeted training, before it shows up on the line.

Standardization is not about making every instructor the same person. It is about making sure every pilot is measured against the same standard, and that the standard is a good one.


Captain Thrainn Arnar Thrainsson, Type Rating Examiner, AvioSon Training Solutions

 
 
 

Comments


NordAero.png

​

​

© 2026 by AvioSon. 

 

Contact us

bottom of page